Greater Boston · Buyers & sellers
Check an agent's CMA with your own math
When you get a comparative market analysis from an agent, a second look with clear math helps you understand the range—not fight the person who prepared it. This page walks through a short self-check and points to RAAM tools that already exist on this site.
What a CMA is (and why a second look helps)
A comparative market analysis (CMA) estimates what a home might sell for by looking at similar properties nearby. Agents use judgment: which sales count, how to weight differences, and how the current market feels.
A second look is not about distrust. It is about understanding the inputs so you can ask better questions, spot gaps, and walk into pricing or offer talks with your own notes. Your agent still brings local knowledge, negotiation skill, and access you will not get from a spreadsheet alone.
A five-step self-check
Use this alongside the CMA you already have. Keep a short list of the sales you would have included and any you would have skipped.
- 01
Pick comparable sales
Same neighborhood or nearby streets when you can, similar size and property type, and sold recently—not listed last year. Note which sales your agent included.
- 02
Adjust for big differences
Condition, finished basement, garage, lot, and major renovations move value. Small cosmetic differences usually matter less than square footage and location.
- 03
Compare price per square foot
Divide each sale price by living area. A cluster of similar $/sq ft is more useful than one outlier that matches a desired number.
- 04
Look at the range, not one number
A CMA is a reasoned range. Ask where your home sits in that range and what would push the estimate up or down.
- 05
Ask which comps were left out—and why
Every analysis leaves something out. A good conversation covers the near-misses and the reason they were excluded, not only the sales that made the cut.
How to do the math with RAAM
RAAM Homes is decision support, not a brokerage CMA product. Use these existing pages to build your own range and compare listings—then bring those notes back to your agent.
What's your home worth?
Get a personalized price range from live listings in your ZIP, including market $/sq ft and the adjustments applied. Asking prices typically run above final sale prices—so treat this as a parallel check, not a substitute for sold comps on the CMA.
Build a Custom RAAM analyzer
Weight value for money and other factors the way you care about them, then score listings against that profile. Useful when you are buying and want the same lens on every house.
Compare listings side by side
After you build an analyzer, Compare lines up two to five properties on the same weights from your dashboard (a paid plan may be required). Helps you see trade-offs before you treat any one number as "the" answer.
Quick score a listing
Paste a Zillow URL for a fast preview score when you want a lightweight pass before a full analysis.
How value for money is weighted
Explains how RAAM thinks about price per square foot in scoring. It is not a sold-comp CMA engine—read it so you know what the score is (and is not) doing.
How to compare houses with weighted scoring
A practical guide to ranking homes by your priorities instead of a generic portal score—useful when the CMA conversation turns into "which house is better for us?"
Ask
Ask a plain-language question about buying, selling, or how RAAM works. Bring the answer into your agent conversation if it helps.
Smart questions for a listing
Paste a Zillow URL for listing-specific questions to bring to your realtor or inspector—alongside the CMA self-check above.
Gaps we are honest about
- RAAM does not currently offer a first-party tool that pulls closed comparable sales the way a brokerage CMA does. Worth uses active listing asking prices.
- No dedicated worksheet yet for manually adjusting comps (condition, garage, lot, finishes). Use your own notes for now.
- We do not show Greater Boston sale-price or days-on-market figures on this page until we have verified sources for them.
Questions to ask your agent
Tone matters. You are collaborating on a clear picture, not cross-examining anyone. Agents are partners in the transaction—these prompts keep the math visible.
- Which sales did you rely on most, and why those over others nearby?
- How did you adjust for condition, updates, or lot differences?
- Where does this estimate sit in the range—conservative, middle, or optimistic?
- What would need to be true for a higher or lower list (or offer) price?
- If the market softens or heats up before we list or close, how would you revisit this?
Disclaimer
This page is educational only. It is not an appraisal, home inspection, brokerage service, or legal, tax, or financial advice. RAAM Homes (including Custom RAAM on raam.homes) is operated by Dwellchecker Labs LLC and provides general information and software tools. Scores and estimates organize research using the inputs you provide; they are not a substitute for licensed professionals.
Always verify facts on the ground and consult your agent, appraiser, attorney, or lender for decisions specific to your situation. Full terms are on the Terms page.
Start with a parallel range
Run Worth for a ZIP-based range, or build an analyzer if you are comparing listings to buy. Then talk it through with your agent.